Home > Crossway Blog > Four Temptations: How Internet Habits Can Cripple Book Reading

Four Temptations: How Internet Habits Can Cripple Book Reading

Fragmented Browsing vs. Sustained Comprehension
The Internet is designed to encourage us to browse information, not to slowly read and digest it. We jump from link to link and are driven by distraction. Book reading, on the other hand, can’t happen without disciplined and sustained linear concentration. Instead of browsing for fragments of information, we must learn to become deep thinkers who work hard to comprehend (2 Tim. 2:7).

If we fill our lives with fragments of information, our brains will adapt and our concentration will weaken. We will begin to find articles, chapters, and books increasingly demanding as our attention spans shrivel. Eventually we will find it difficult to stroll through long stretches of prose. Book readers must work to sharpen their attention. Like marathon runners who train daily to stretch their endurance, book readers must discipline themselves to read one book for thirty to sixty or ninety minutes at a time, struggling to increase their mental concentration.

Reacting vs. Thinking

Traditionally, a reader selected one book and sat alone in a reading chair. When great ideas were encountered, the reader internalized those ideas and reflected on them. If the reader encountered points of disagreement, the reader also stopped to reflect on what made the point disagreeable. Traditional readers engaged with a book and engaged their thinking.

This has changed with online social interaction. Now, when we come across an idea that we like, we are tempted to quickly react, to share the idea with friends in an e-mail, on Facebook, or on a blog. When we disagree, our initial response is to ask for the input of others. With online access to so many friends, the temptation is to react, not to ponder. Acting upon what we’ve just read, rather than stopping to meditate and think, is an impulse that we bring to reading books. I am quick to Tweet and slow to think. I am quick to Google and slow to ponder.

So ask yourself the next time you read: When you come across a provoking or perplexing portion of a book, what are you more likely to do: react or think? When you are tempted to react, stop, and simply think and meditate about what you are reading.

Ready Access to Information vs. Slowly Digested Life Wisdom

Valuable life wisdom flows out of meditation and deep thought. It’s easy to skim around for information online or to bounce from one fragmented detail to another. But the labor gets heavy when we determine to study a book for the purpose of gaining life wisdom. True learning and true wisdom are the fruit of long-term diligent study and meditation, benefits that we cannot get from books unless we are willing to slow our minds, mute distractions, and carefully think about what we are reading. Of all the people surrounded by data in the information age, Christians should be especially protective of the time required to slowly meditate (Proverbs 4).

Skimming with the Head vs. Delighting with the Heart

Lest we put all the blame on the Internet, however, the hasty reading of books appears to be a problem that predates Google. Puritan Thomas Brooks (1608–1680) faced this problem in seventeenth- century England. Brooks wrote,

Remember, it is not hasty reading, but serious meditating upon holy and heavenly truths, that makes them prove sweet and profitable to the soul. It is not the bee’s touching of the flower that gathers honey, but her abiding for a time upon the flower that draws out the sweet. It is not he that reads most, but he that meditates most, that will prove the choicest, sweetest, wisest, and strongest Christian.

Slow meditation on what we read is not only essential for gaining wisdom, it is also essential for experiencing delight.

In order to feel deeply about spiritual truths we must think deeply. And to think deeply we must read deeply. And to read deeply we must read attentively, not hastily. If we discipline ourselves to read attentively and to think deeply about our reading, we will position our souls to delight. But our souls cannot delight in what our minds merely skim.

Modified from Lit! by Tony Reinke.

September 28, 2011 | Posted in: AAA - BLOG UPDATE,Culture,Life / Doctrine,The Arts,The Christian Life | Author: Lindsay Tully @ 8:58 am | (6) Comments »


  1. Fantastic post. I know that I struggle with wanting to get a second opinion so-to-speak on Google or on a site like Monergism, and I think this problem can leak into our reading and studying of Scripture. If we can’t meditate and think deeply over the most important words we will ever read, then how much effort will we give to lesser matters? Good post and ironically there’s much to think about.

    Comment by Ryan — September 28, 2011 @ 10:35 am

  2. I love this for two reasons:

    1) Because it’s true, period.
    2) Because I appreciate the irony of posting this on a blog, which I wouldn’t have found if I wasn’t wandering around the Internet one day, lol.

    Comment by Don Sartain — September 28, 2011 @ 11:18 am

  3. Good reminders – I find my attention span getting shorter these days and also find I have to make myself take the time think.

    Comment by Bill Jones — September 28, 2011 @ 9:49 pm

  4. Excellent and thought-provoking piece. I particularly love the quotation from Thomas Brooks, which shows that this is a human problem, rather than a 21st Century one.

    Now, please excuse me from further commentary; I must go and meditate on that last paragraph…

    Comment by Sally Oakley — September 30, 2011 @ 5:27 am

  5. Interesting points if a Puritan self discipline is your goal. But forostbit’s not. Some read for gaining wisdoms – that comes from understanding. For that you need knowledge and listening, ‘pondering’ skills and life experience. One shouldn’t spend too much time reading or browsing when there’s life to live. You can glean or suck the marrow from from some juicy proverb but until you’ve lived it, applied it, it’s fruitless head knowledge.

    Comment by Lynn Boyd — July 29, 2014 @ 3:51 pm

  6. I’ve noticed these adverse effect on myself whenever I come across poetry — when was the last time you saw poetry posted? It’s not instant comprehension. It takes time to absorb. And I feel my mind fidgeting so quickly I put it down for something more easily accessible.

    (Does anyone else notice this when they read the Bible?)

    Comment by Ryan Fishel — July 30, 2014 @ 2:54 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a Comment