Sometimes Only Servants See the Miracle
A Meditation on John 2
What’s wrong with the worship leaders? A recent survey of 3,300 worship leaders produced the headline “Only 3.4 percent of worship leaders rate their mental health as excellent.” By comparison, a member of the general US population is 8.5 times more likely (29 percent) to report excellent mental health.1
That’s surprising. To many, it seems that leading a church in corporate worship would be a meaningful and rewarding job. So why doesn’t this meaningful work lead to life satisfaction? Digging down into the details of the survey, the researchers cite issues of authority, expectation, isolation, and conflict.
I have, in different seasons of my life, served as a music volunteer, a vocational Worship Pastor, and as a lay elder and seminary professor. These issues are very familiar (and very personal!) to me. A story in the Gospels has encouraged me. Watching Jesus’s actions and hearing his words has helped me connect the meaningfulness of my worship ministry more directly with my own job and life satisfaction.
Biblical Worship
Matthew Westerholm
Presenting a redemptive-historical look at worship from Genesis to Christ, Matthew Westerholm provides believers with a unified vision of worship that is not only biblically faithful but theologically rich and Christ-centered.
The Wedding at Cana: Celebrities and Servants
In John 2:1–11, Jesus and his disciples attend a wedding at Cana in Galilee. When the wedding festivities ran out of wine, Jesus turned water into wine, saving the wedding. The passage tells us that this was “the first of his signs” and how Jesus “manifested his glory” (John 2:11).
Notice the four types of people at this wedding and consider them from the most prominent to the least: the Wedding Party, the Master of the Feast, the guests, and the servants.
First, we see the Wedding Party. The groom and the bride were the honored ones at this wedding, the upfront centers of attention. The event was held in their honor, celebrating them with full festivities. Using today’s terminology, their pictures were on the invitations and their names were on the cover of the program. When they walk into the room, everyone stands in respect, and when they kiss, everyone squeals in approval. When they leave, everyone gathers to honor their departure. At this wedding, the groom and the bride are the celebrities.
A second type of person at this wedding is the Master of the Feast. Think of this character like an ancient wedding coordinator. He oversees the money and supervises the details. He coordinates the entrances, administers the provisions, and tells everyone what to do. At this wedding, the Master of the Feast is the authority.
A third category of people at this wedding are the wedding guests. Of all the people at this wedding, the wedding guests have the easiest time, simply attending, celebrating, and enjoying the wedding. Their responsibilities include . . . well, nothing burdensome. They eat the banquet feast, clink their glasses, and cheer. At this wedding, the wedding guests have felicity.
Meanwhile, a fourth group of people are hard at work—the servants. For the servants, the wedding is a time of labor, compliance, and invisibility. They see the chaos behind the scenes and they hear the family arguments. They fill the glasses, clean the messes, and try to remain unseen. At this wedding, the servants have utility.
Recognizing the Temptations
Having read this story and identified these four groups of people, worship leaders should recognize the temptations to assume the wrong role. Every minister recognizes the temptation of celebrity. It feels good to see our names on the program, and it’s nice to be recognized when we walk into a room. We can recognize the temptation of authority. It feels good to be in charge, to make decisions, and have things go our way. We also recognize the temptation of felicity, to desire to simply sit back and enjoy what’s happening.
Worship leaders know that they are supposed to be the servants. But while we know serving is meaningful work, it’s honestly not fun. Worship musicians know they should serve, but is that their only motivation . . . obligation? Or is there something greater available?
The Wedding at Large: Silent Miracle and Servant Mentality
There is something greater available, which we discover in the text of John 2 when we pay close attention. Begin by noticing how Jesus performed the miracle. Like the “b” in the word “subtle,” Jesus silently performed this miracle without a mystical gesture, a puff of smoke, or any verbal “hocus-pocus.” The text simply describes “the water now become wine” (John 2:9). This miracle, this manifestation of Christ’s glory, occurred with the jars the servants found, the water they brought, and the command they followed.
Here’s my point. Only the servants saw the miracle.
The groom and the bride were the celebrities. They were the upfront “stars” of the wedding. Celebrated and adored, they were the center of all the attention of the crowds. But they never saw the miracle and never knew where the wine came from.
We are his servants, but what fortunate servants we are!
The master of the feast was the authority of the wedding, overseeing the details and telling everyone what to do. And even though he unknowingly and ironically testified to the miracle (a delightful semi-regular occurrence in the Gospels), he did not experience it. John 2:9 tells us he “did not know” where the wine had come from.
The wedding guests enjoyed the felicity of the wedding. They simply attended and “drunk freely” (John 2:10). The implication might even be that their drunkenness has made them unaware of what happened.
Again, only the servants saw the miracle.
Implications: Recognize the Host and Serve
This is a common theme in the kingdom of God and in the church of Christ.2 As we become more familiar with the Gospels, we discover Jesus never simply attends a wedding. Jesus often begins a story as an outsider that soon becomes the host. John provides several stories of Christ providing wine to wedding guests (here in John 2:1–11), water to well visitors (John 4:4–42), bread to hungry crowds (John 6:1–71), and foot washing to travelers (John 13:1–20).3 This fills believers with faith and helps us believe him when he promises to prepare a place for us (John 14:1–6).4
When believers assume our proper role as his servants, we acknowledge that Jesus is the host of this gathering. This is his party. He is the star of the show, the celebrity of the occasion. To quote Shai Linne, “He’s not in the limelight; he is the limelight.”5 He is the master of the feast, the authority of the gathering. At your church this Sunday, the world would consider some people more famous than others, some people more important than others. But from heaven’s impartial perspective, our churches have no celebrities or stand-alone authorities (James 2:1–9). Even the most well-known pastors and the most prominent apostles, Paul tells us, are “your servants for Jesus’s sake” (2 Cor. 4:5).
If you would like to see the miracles, if you would like to experience the manifestations of Christ’s glory, do the work of the servant. Just as Mary said to the servants at the wedding, “Do whatever he tells you” (John 2:5). And they did—completely! When Jesus instructed them to “fill the jars with water,” the servants “filled them up to the brim” (John 2:7).
We are his servants, but what fortunate servants we are! This is how worship leaders and others can connect the work they know to be meaningful with the sense of personal reward and life satisfaction. Only servants get to see the miracles, get to see Christ’s glory manifested, and believe.
Notes:
- Worship Leader Research, “Worship Leaders 8.5X Less Likely to Report Excellent Mental Health Than U.S. Adults,” March, 3 2026. https://worshipleaderresearch.com/worship-leaders-mental-health/ While usually “work meaningfulness [is] strongly associated with a variety of positive outcomes,” including job satisfaction, hope, positive affect, and overall life satisfaction, even the worship leaders who “experience their work as deeply meaningful” do not report the expected job and life satisfaction that researchers expect. Cites the work of Jing Hu and Jacob Hirsh, “The Benefits of Meaningful Work: A Meta-Analysis,” Academy of Management 2017, no. 1 (Nov 30, 2017). https://doi.org/10.5465/AMBPP.2017.13866abstract.
- A similar occurrence happens later in the gospel of John, when Jesus returns to Cana (John 4:46–54). Jesus healed the son of an official (a man with authority), but only his servants saw the miracle happen (John 4:51–52). See the discussion in James M. Hamilton, In the Beginning was the Word, 61–80, esp. the chart on pg. 65.
- In Luke 24:13–35, Jesus begins by joining two men on their journey to Emmaus, but by the end, he’s taking, breaking, and distributing the food, hosting the meal.
- See the discussion of this theme in Joshua Jipp, Reading the Gospels as Christian Scripture, 297–298.
- From the song, “Jesus is Alive,” track 12 of The Atonement (2008).
Mathew Westerholm is the author of Biblical Worship: A Christ-Centered Practical Theology.
Related Articles
The Worship That God Will Not Accept
There is a truth we have to wrap our minds around regarding worship that comes from Psalm 51:16: There is worship that God does not accept. Already you may be somewhat uncomfortable.
How Believers Can Engage More Wholeheartedly in Congregational Singing
When we gather as the people of God, it’s more than just a people getting together in a room. It is a high and holy privilege to gather in the name of Jesus.
What Happens If Reverence Is Absent in Our Christian Lives?
If reverence is absent in our Christian lives, we’re missing the whole point of our lives being surrendered to God.
Podcast: How Reverence Changes the Way You Worship, Suffer, and Grow (Laura Story)
Laura Story discusses the importance of reverence towards God and how it helps us through suffering, changes our worship, and is the soil for spiritual growth.
50% Off Books & Bibles for Teens
50% off - Gifts For Little Ones